Cover graphic for Best Baseball Catcher's Mitts: Our Top Picks for the 2027 Season

Catching

Best Baseball Catcher's Mitts: Our Top Picks for the 2027 Season

Our picks for the best catcher's mitts for high school, college and youth catchers, plus how to size a mitt by age.

Zach Kerr

Updated October 30, 2026 · 3 min read

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page.

Contents

A catcher's mitt is built differently from every other glove on the field: more padding, a closed pocket and sizing by circumference. Below are our picks for high school, college and pro catchers, the best mitts for the cost, and a youth section with sizes by age. Looking for a fielding glove for another position? See our best baseball gloves guide.

How we picked: we compared mitts from All-Star, Rawlings, Wilson, Mizuno and Nokona on size, leather, padding and pocket, using the details each brand and retailer publishes. Prices change often, so check the store page when you click through.

Best All Around Catcher's Mitts

For Advanced High School, College & Pro Players

Shop Now
Sizes: 32, 33.5, 34, 35Colors: 2Category: GlovesCategory: Catching

Shop Now

Shop Now

Shop Now

Shop Now

Best Catcher's Mitts for the Cost

For High School & College Players

Shop Now

Shop Now

Shop Now

How to Choose the Right Catcher's Mitt

When selecting a catcher's mitt, prioritize pocket depth, as a deeper pocket provides better control and reduces pop-outs. Mitt size ranges from 32" to 34", with larger sizes offering more surface area but potentially slowing transfer times. Webbing is key—closed web designs offer more support, especially for fast pitches. Consider break-in time; high-quality leather mitts mold to your hand but need more time to break in.

Interested in new gear? Here's our breakdown of the best catchers gear for 2027

Materials for Catcher's Mitts

  • Steerhide: Durable and holds shape well.
  • Kangaroo Leather: Lightweight yet strong.
  • Cowhide: Quicker break-in, ideal for comfort.

Pro Features for Catcher's Mitts

Look for reinforced palm padding for protection, moisture-wicking linings to stay dry, and quick transfer designs to improve game speed.

Maintaining Your Catcher's Mitt

Regularly condition the mitt to keep it soft and prevent cracking. Store it properly in a cool, dry place to maintain its shape. Break it in with oil, light use, and glove mallets for the best fit.

Catcher’s Mitt Sizing

Catcher's mitts are measured around the outside of the mitt, not from the heel to the tip like a fielding glove. Adult mitts usually run 32" to 34.5", and youth mitts start around 29.5". Smaller mitts are easier for young hands to close, while bigger mitts give a larger target. Baseball Monkey's sizing guide is a good starting point.

Best Youth Catcher's Mitts

Youth mitts are smaller and lighter so a young catcher can actually squeeze the mitt shut. A common mistake is buying a 33" adult mitt to grow into. If your catcher can't close it, they'll stab at pitches and drop more of them. These are rough sizes by age from Baseball Monkey's catcher's mitt sizing chart:

  • Under 7: 29.5" to 30"
  • Ages 8 to 10: 30" to 31"
  • Ages 11 to 13: 30" to 34.5"
  • 14 and up: 32" to 34.5"

Our catalog doesn't carry a true youth mitt under 32" yet. For an older youth or young teen catcher moving up, these are the smallest mitts we cover. All-Star lists its 32" Pro Elite (CM3000XSBT) as a smaller mitt for young catchers in its protective catalog.

Shop Now
Colors: Black, TanCategory: Gloves

Shop Now
Colors: Black, Blue, RedCategory: Gloves

Shop Now
Colors: Blonde, BlueCategory: Gloves

For a full set of gear, see our catcher's gear guide and catcher's cleats.

Catcher's Mitt FAQ

What size catcher's mitt does my kid need? Go by age and hand size. Under 7 usually fits 29.5" to 30", ages 8 to 10 fit 30" to 31", and ages 11 to 13 range from 30" to 34.5" depending on hand size.

Can a catcher use a regular baseball glove? Not for long. A fielding glove has far less padding, so a catcher taking pitches all game will feel it in the hand. For other positions, see our glove guide.

How is a catcher's mitt measured? By the circumference around the outside of the mitt. Fielding gloves are measured from the heel to the tip of the index finger.

How do I break in a catcher's mitt? Play catch with it as much as you can and close it around a ball between sessions. Our break-in guide covers what to avoid.

Similar Posts:

Share this guide

FacebookXEmail

Zach Kerr

Zach is a former college pitcher & Founder of Baseball Near You.

Keep reading